Rankings

Rankings: Every Disney Live Action Remake From Worst to Best

Disney has announced a large slate of live action remakes to their beloved animated properties to be released within the next few years.  Although Alice in Wonderland was released in 2010, the trend started in 2014 with the release of Maleficent and has continued ever since.  With Beauty and the Beast coming out this weekend, I thought it be a good time to take a look at the remakes put out in theaters thus far.

#6: Alice in Wonderland (2010): Full of all the weirdness of the animated film but none of the heart, Alice in Wonderland largely succeeded at the box office for its 3-D technology coming off of the heels of James Cameron’s Avatar.  Johnny Depp is just plain annoying as the Mad Hatter, continuing his tradition of playing zany characters in a lot of makeup.  The visuals are certainly impressive, but after awhile they just become nauseating as they overwhelm the audience.  Alice in Wonderland was yet another disappointment in the recent filmography of Tim Burton.

Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score: 52%

Metacritic Score: 53

MovieBabble Score: D

Alice in Wonderland
image via Movie Lovers Reviews

#5: Maleficent (2014): Angelina Jolie pitches in a great performance as Maleficent in the lead role, but the film as a whole falters mightily.  I’m never one to penalize a film for trying something different with the source material it comes from, but Maleficent went way too far, completely changing the character of Maleficent into a misunderstood protector of Sleeping Beauty.  For comparison, this change-up would be like if there was an origin story to Voldemort where we found out that he actually protected Harry Potter as a child.  Other than this fatal flaw, Maleficent offers nothing noteworthy to make up for it, leading to a disappointing film.

Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score: 50%

Metacritic Score: 56

MovieBabble Score: D+

Maleficent
image via Disney Movies

#4: Pete’s Dragon (2016): Sweet yet forgetful, Disney took a chance with this lesser beloved property and made a charming film that unfortunately failed to speak to audiences like the other movies on this list.  Pete’s Dragon has a gentle, more restrained feel than many Disney films despite having a big, green fury dragon at the center of the story.  While the film doesn’t have that “wow” factor that you look for in a magical Disney retelling, the film filled with nice performances from Robert Redford, Bryce Dallas Howard, and Oakes Fegley.

Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score: 87%

Metacritic Score: 71

MovieBabble Score: B

Pete's Dragon
image via rogerebert.com

#3: Cinderella (2015): Kenneth Branagh helps to do what Maleficent should have done by adding little twists to the story of Cinderella but keep the central story intact.  Lily James was perfect casting as Cinderella, offering all the feel good charm and loveliness that we expect from the famous character.  I give a lot of credit to Kenneth Branagh for creating a different feel to this version of Cinderella, making the film feel like a Victorian-era tale.  This was the film that validated the need for Disney to move forward with their plans to create live action remakes as it perfectly balanced new qualities with old qualities that we love.  Cate Blanchett gets special recognition for her suitably hateful performance as the Wicked Stepmother.

Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score: 83%

Metacritic Score: 67

MovieBabble Score: A-

Cinderella
image via ComingSoon.net

#2: Beauty and the Beast (2017): Although some moments of the iconic animated film don’t translate very well to live-action, Beauty and the Beast recaptures a solid amount of the magic that made the original so great.  The film is solidly cast, with Luke Evans perfectly capturing the cockiness of Gaston.  It would be a crime if this film wasn’t nominated for either best production design or costume design as the film looks absolutely gorgeous from start to finish.  Although the film largely re-films the animated movie, the 2017 version of Beauty and Beast adds some nice little touches to the lore to update the film for today’s society.

Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score: 71%

Metacritic Score: 65

MovieBabble Score: A-

Beauty and the Beast
image via Digital Spy

*To read my review of Beauty and the Beast, please click here.

#1: The Jungle Book (2016): To this day I still can’t believe that this scene was filmed on a green screen in Los Angeles and not in a jungle somewhere in the rain forest.  No film should ever have an excuse for poor CGI now that this movie has been released.  Jon Favreau once again shows how great of a director he is when given the right material as The Jungle Book even improves on the original.  While the film neither commits to taking the source material in a new direction or staying close to the original, the film has great performances from Neel Sethi as the only character in live action as well as Idris Elba, Bill Murray, and Ben Kingsley in voice roles.

Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score: 95%

Metacritic Score: 77

MovieBabble Score: A-

The Jungle Book
image via Wizard Dojo

Thanks for reading!  How would you make your list?  Comment down below and let me know!

If you enjoyed this article, please feel free to like, share, and subscribe.

What movie topic should I discuss next?  Whether it be old or new, the choice is up to you!

*Note: Alice Through the Looking Glass is based off an animated film that was not produced by Disney

35 Comments

    1. It was an Alice Through the Looking Glass animated film but according to my research it was produced by an Australian Studio and not Walt Disney so it appeared that Disney was not involved

      1. But, is this Disney remake BASED on that Australian animated film? I thought this remake was just a sequel to the 2010 film and although sharing the similar title with the Australian film, it’s not an adaptation of that?

  1. Can’t even remotely agree on Alice. Loved the live-action, generally despise the cartoon–it doesn’t have a heart or a feel for Carroll’s quirkiness, just a lot of stock cartoon wackiness. Though the two are separate enough I’d count the live action version as an unrelated take on Carroll.

  2. Great list! I differ a little just because I really didn’t enjoy Maleficent. So maybe Alice in Wonderland might get a little higher for myself especially since I do like Mia Wasikowska. And I love the story of Cinderella so it might rank a little higher than Jungle Book but they are pretty much neck to neck :). Still have to see Pete’s Dragon though…hopefully soon.

    Will you be updating this ranking as more live action Disney remakes come out?

  3. Never was a huge fan of the animated Jungle Book but really loved the live action version. Loved the casting, particularly Bill Murray. Only other movie on this list I’ve seen is Alice in Wonderland, which I’d agree was not great. But I might watch Cinderella now based on your review. Thanks!

  4. I was suitably impressed with The Jungle Book and cannot wait for Jon Favreau’s version of The Lion King. Although I did love Maleficent and that would be my number 2, with Cinderella 3rd and Pete’s a dragon 5th. Xx

  5. Of the movies on this list I’ve only seen Cinderella, Maleficent, and Alice in Wonderland, but I agreed with your points on those three. Never cared for the Alice story in general. Maleficent had a great premise and chickened out by turning her into a good guy. Cinderella was sweet and heartwarming with gorgeous sets and costumes.

      1. Nice! Would you be interested in sharing any of your articles with our readers on moviepilot.com? I’m a community manager here for the site and would love for you to get involved!

Leave a Reply

Donate to MovieBabbleSee Our GoFundMe
+ +
%d bloggers like this: