Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (2017): An Uneven Follow-Up

In August of 2014, we were all dazzled and surprised at the first major risk by Marvel Studios in Guardians of the Galaxy.  Filled with crazy characters and a delightfully different tone, Guardians worked on practically all fronts.  Now, after three long years of waiting, the Guardians are back!  But did they deliver on the thrills this time around?  The following Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 review will be spoiler free.

Background

Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 is once again directed by James Gunn and brings back the great cast of the first film that included Chris Pratt, Zoe Saldana, and Dave Bautista alongside some new additions such as Kurt Russell.  After the events of the first film, the Guardians have taken up a new job for a race of people that are entirely gold by protecting some of their property.  However, after the planned deal goes awry, a man named Ego (who we later find out to be Starlord’s father) saves the day and takes all the Guardians to his home world.  Everything seems to be going along just fine until a more sinister plan is uncovered by the Guardians which threatens the fate of the universe.

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via Den of Geek

Background…Continued

As you are most definitely aware, the MCU is ramping up into high gear for the culmination of all their movies into the massive, highly anticipated Infinity Wars that is scheduled to hit theaters on May 4th, 2018.  After Iron Man kick-started this whole superhero craze in 2008, it’s pretty incredible to think that Infinity Wars is an actual movie that will exist in a year’s time.

But that’s not why you clicked on this Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 review.  You want to hear about the highly anticipated follow-up to what many consider their favorite MCU film.

Chris Pratt was quoted saying that Guardians 2 was going to be the biggest spectacle movie ever created.  While he was obviously speaking with some hyperbole, there was definitely some merit to those remarks.  When you combine great characters returning with what seemed to be crazy, colorful celestial landscapes, who knows, maybe Pratt wasn’t smoking something before he dropped that hot take.

Either way, we all know that we were looking forward to this film.

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via Alamo Drafthouse

What I Liked

From a big picture perspective, I truly admire James Gunn’s gall in making Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 a really weird film.  Films that take place in the Marvel Cinematic Universe are consistently good, but few transcend the cookie-cutter nature of the template present in each film to create great success.  But Gunn has put his stamp on this franchise, making it one of the most different (and likable) franchises that we have today.  There are a lot of plot points and story beats that are so bizarre and strange that a ton of credit needs to be given to Marvel Studios for finally allowing themselves to branch out past genre conventions.  You know your movie is different when Pac-Man makes an important appearance in a pivotal action sequence.

And yes, you read that last sentence correctly.

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via Digital Spy

James Gunn’s sensibilities bleed into the nooks and crannies of the script for Guardians 2 as well.  While I found the soundtrack of Vol. 2 to be less catchy than its predecessor, there was one song in particular that is actually woven into the story and serves a major purpose in the growing relationship between Starlord and Ego.  Little moments like are what make James Gunn an incredible talent and make his films full of heart and subtext.

What I Like…Continued

But these smaller moments are not the only witty, fun bits to view in this sequel.  Guardians of the Galaxy, for better or for worse, may be even funnier than the original.  Dave Bautista steals the show as Drax once again.  It’s clear that he has grown even more comfortable in this role, spouting deadpan insults with glee.  There are a lot of great character dynamics in Guardians 2, but one of the best may be Drax’s relationship with newcomer Mantis.  It’s mean-spirited, charming, and hilarious.

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via Raising Whasians

There are certainly some character beats that really stuck with me, especially from Yondu in a surprise turn.  There’s an excess amount of heart and discussion of family here that really works, even if it wasn’t all necessary.  With all its flaws, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 keeps you invested with its great, likable characters.

For those wondering, yes, Baby Groot is adorable.  Get in line for your toys now!

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via Digital Spy

What I Disliked

For the all the lovely parts of Guardians 2, the plot is a serious mess.

I struggled coming up with a plot synopsis for this review, mostly due to the fact that the plot for Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 doesn’t really kick in until the last fifteen minutes.  This film brings even more jokes and character moments than the first film, but it unfortunately puts the story on the back-burner to do so.

After a quick, busy action sequence that starts off the movie, the film dips into a lull for a majority of the film’s run time of which it never fully recovered.  Once a majority of the characters arrive in a certain location, they remain there for the rest of movie.

This attribute isn’t necessarily a negative, bigger budget movies that take place in more confined locations have produced great products in the past like last year’s Star Trek Beyond with a ton of entertainment.  However, it’s what the film does once that location is set that makes or breaks the film.

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via Comicbook.com

What I Disliked…Continued

Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 has that issue of having events occur but having a small amount of them actually move the plot forward or add anything to the story, giving the film a fluffy, underwritten feel.  I wonder if Gunn and Co. were too concerned telling jokes to make a plot that captivates its audience.

There’s a serious pacing issue to Guardians.  Nothing is very exhilarating for the middle portion of the film.  I don’t need wall to wall action from a movie to work, but there needs to a moment that breaks up the character beats so that I don’t slump into my seat and yawn.  I admire James Gunn for trying to give a major focus to all our lovable characters, but it came at the expense of great storytelling as the entire middle portion felt incredibly repetitive with every character trying to tell their life story.  This movie could have easily had twenty minutes stripped away and it would have been a serious benefit.

We already love these characters for the heart their backstories were given in the first film.  Why bog down the second film with a retread of those same character beats?

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via SlashFilm

There’s also some pretty awful CGI and green screen and hand here that really took me out of the film.

The last criticism I have (before the comment section eats me alive) is that Marvel once again fails to give a compelling villain…in one instance.  There’s one villain group that felt so forced and cheesy that it should have been in a 70’s campy, sci-fi adventure.

Conclusion

Unfortunately for my movie-going experience (and possibly for my comment section and self-esteem), Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 was a bit of a letdown for this critic.  I love the Guardians, but not necessarily the film they were in.  It gets a B.  This film is lucky that James Gunn has crafted some incredible characters that I will always love.  It might have saved this movie for me.

guardians of the galaxy vol. 2 review

image via The Next Web

Thanks for reading my Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 review!  What did you think of the movie?  Comment down below and let me know!

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to MovieBabble via email below:

What movie topic should I discuss next?  Whether it be old or new, the choice is up to you!

Nick Kush

A current college student, Nick founded MovieBabble in October of 2016 in order to grow his own movie knowledge as well as share his own thoughts with others in a streamlined fashion. As MovieBabble continues to grow, Nick hopes to one day become a reputable critic that many turn to first for a quality movie review.

You may also like...

15 Responses

  1. It’s rare to find people actually willing to criticize the MCU. Great Review

  2. dominhk says:

    Nice balanced review. In fact, I think you were pretty kind to the film. For me it committed the cardinal sin by boring me. Honestly, from the opening sequence where the Baby Groot marketing campaign kicked off I thought the film was in trouble, kinda “Oh shit, they’ve played the Baby Groot card IN THE FIRST SCENE!” This was then mirrored at the very end of the film by the credits, yep, the credits let me down. Whoever thought replacing various names and roles with red “Baby Groot” text was in any way clever or amusing should go and have a long hard think about just what they have done. It was just irritating. “There’s the words Baby Groot in red, oh wait it has changed to “Dave Montero – Foley, hey wait, there it is again, oh and it has changed again, wait there agai . . .and another, and anoth . . .and there too . . .” and-so-on-and-so-forth. Such a shame, I was so up for this film, in the end, I preferred Fast 8, which I saw in a double header with this. Cheers.

    • MovieBabble says:

      Thanks for your thoughts! Surprisingly, I felt that Baby Groot was solidly mixed into the rest of the film. This film certainly has some major narrative issues, but (and it’s a credit to the original) that I just love these characters so much that they elevate some incredibly thin material to a point.

  3. TheWarner says:

    I just returned from the theater, and I agree with most of what you wrote. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2’s plot was all over the place. It also wasn’t as funny as the first, but stylistically I thought it was great. I guess I’ve been spoiled by the Captain America movies, in that each sequel has been better than the previous film, in my opinion. I think the age regression was great. I was just thankful it didn’t look like the crappy CG used in Tron: Legacy or Terminator Salvation. 😏

    I’m concerned about Marvel’s Infinity Wars movies, as I’ve hated the last few Marvel sequels, Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Captain America: Civil War excluded. I didn’t like Thor: The Dark World, Iron Man 3, or The Avengers: Age of Ultron, which was just a mess. I wonder if they will be able to give us a cohesive plot, given they have to mesh so many storylines and characters together. Hopefully Thor: Ragnarok will be good.

    • MovieBabble says:

      I thought the age regression was amazing! A lot of the time there’s an uncanny valley effect with the technology but I couldn’t tell at all!

  4. Kylan Riley says:

    You and I have pretty much the same views on this movie. I’m glad I’m not the only one that can criticize the MCU

  5. You’ll probably disagree, but I think that you’re both right and wrong about the plot. I think the only plot that James Gunn was concerned with was the deepening of the relationships of the guardians. The first movie took them from acquaintances to “work friends” and in this movie they move from actual friends to family, fast and furious style. The plot that unfolds (or doesn’t) is background noise or is only supposed to serve this end. There are a few scenes in the movie where large action set pieces actually happen in the background. Something seemingly innocuous or some funny back and forth happens in the foreground because that is where Gunn wants our attention. I can see, however, if you pull focus to the background events how it can seem like the plot is a mess.

    • MovieBabble says:

      I have no problem with a big budget movie that focuses on characters and relationships over explosions. But when you make it repetitive and monotonous like Gunn did a little then I get bored as a viewer.

      • I get that and I do agree with you. It was good enough for me though because by the time something might have turned me off I was already hooked. I actually like it more than the original because of the character depth and evolution, but in no way do I think it’s without flaws.

      • MovieBabble says:

        And I don’t blame you for liking it as much as you do! There’s still a great deal of fun to be had. All film is subjective anyway. I’d never be mad at someone who feels differently about a film than me, it only makes discussion more interesting!

  1. May 6, 2017

    […] *To read my full review of Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, please click here. […]

  2. May 10, 2017

    […] *To read my full review of Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, please click here. […]

  3. May 11, 2017

    […] article. If you haven’t done so already (or if you haven’t seen the film), check out my spoiler free review.  For the rest of you, let’s get […]

Make Your Thoughts Heard!

Donate to MovieBabbleSee Our GoFundMe
+ +
%d bloggers like this: