Advertisements

Is the Russian Roulette Sequence in ‘The Deer Hunter’ One of the Best Movie Scenes Ever Made?

The Deer Hunter

For the longest time, The Deer Hunter was one of those movies that I knew I should watch, but never got around to doing so, that is until my father essentially forced me to sit down and watch it like I was deliberately insulting him for putting it off for so long. I imagine that many others have similar experiences with other films.

I write today as a happy man because my dad sat me down to watch this epic film. (Well, the film made me incredibly depressed, but you get the idea.) I now consider The Deer Hunter as one of America’s finest films. So does AFI, who placed it at number 53 on their list of the 100 greatest American films of all time. I guess my dad knows a thing or two. (Don’t get cocky, Paul.)

The Deer Hunter is a beast of a film, clocking in at over three hours and covering some of the darkest themes there. Though it mostly enwraps itself in a meditative state (which holds some of Robert De Niro’s finest work), it quickly moves to bouts of grandiose violence like something out of Grindhouse. It’s powerful, subtle, and everything in between.

the deer hunter

image via The Film Stage

And then there’s the Russian roulette scene, easily the most famous scene in the movie (only rivaled by the other Russian roulette scene near the end of the film). Though having seen the movie many times at that point when I first watched it with him, my father made some sounds of agony during that scene that I still remember to this day. I can’t say I was blaming him — I was doing the exact same thing! I have an image of De Niro maniacally laughing as he pulls the trigger on a gun pressed up against his Temple and lives to talk about it seared into brain. It’s one of the reason why I think it’s one of the best sequences ever put to film.

The Controversy

One cannot examine the Russian roulette scene without mentioning its criticisms. There’s been a lot discussion over the years about the legitimacy of such a Russian roulette game taking place during the Vietnam War. Those that covered the war have noted that not a single case of the Vietcong using Russian roulette on POWs was ever documented. Peter Arnett, who received the Pulitzer Prize for his coverage of the war, said “the central metaphor of the movie is simply a bloody lie.” Director Michael Cimino later stated that he had news clippings from abroad that confirmed the use of Russian roulette during the war, though he never specified which articles he was referring to.

the deer hunter

image via The Wrap

…And More Controversy

The film and the scene of interest also came under fire for its apparent one-sided view of the war, many calling its depiction of the Vietnamese quite egregious. People have gone back and forth on this issue since the film premiered back in 1978. One of the more infamous examples was when Jane Fonda called the film racist despite admitting that she hadn’t seen the film.

Many foreign bodies also spoke out against The Deer Hunter and more specifically the Russian roulette scene, leading to walk-outs at the 29th Berlin International Film Festival in 1979.

Calling this scene a “lightning rod” is a bit of an understatement.

Artistic License at its Finest

As for me, I side with legend Roger Ebert who said the following:

…it is the organizing symbol of the film: Anything you can believe about the game, about its deliberately random violence, about how it touches the sanity of men forced to play it, will apply to the war as a whole. It is a brilliant symbol because, in the context of this story, it makes any ideological statement about the war superfluous.

the deer hunter

image via Reading at Recess

I truly empathize with those that have a differing opinion on the matter; there are other extremely valid ways to interpret this in-your-face scene. The Deer Hunter is a tough film to swallow; it pulls you along without a care for your disposition in a way that is undeniably shocking. It’s all in service of one idea: war is Hell. That’s not necessarily a unique perspective, but combined with the particulars of the film, I believe that The Deer Hunter and the Russian roulette scene take on a meaning that defies what many find troubling about it.

From the film’s eerily accurate representation of the steel mills in 1960’s Pittsburgh to a wonderfully extended Russian Orthodox wedding ceremony, The Deer Hunter is a big ol’ hunk of Americana; it’s a deeply American story that wants to express the effects of PTSD and the loss of innocence that comes with war and the unnecessary degradation of morality that comes from foolish acts of violence by the United States.

Though Cimino and others have explained that the film isn’t explicitly anti-war, one can absolutely take away some feelings that tag along with that sentiment. As we see later, Christopher Walken’s Nick is lost after what happened to him in the war; nothing can save him. That along with the brutal hardship that everyone else faces after the war shows how mindless and pointless war can become on individual level, forcing some to play games of pointless and violent chance to reap any benefits at all. War brings out the worst in all of us (on both sides), turning us into savage animals, unstable martyrs, self-doubting internalists, or a combination of the three. We see both the slow creep and upfront barbarity of inhumanity told through the opposing forces in this illustration of the Vietnam War.

It’s may not be historically accurate, but it packs a powerful thematic punch.

the deer hunter

image via The Soul of the Plot

Unbelievable Tension

On a technical level, Cimino walks a line between being up close and personal with the actors and stepping back to soak everything in, allowing you look deeply into the expressions of De Niro and Walken in real-time as you see the barrel of the gun slowly uncoil. It’s one of the most human and terrifying moments I’ve ever witnessed when adding in the context of the film (you’ve already spent well over an hour with these characters at this point in the film at a very emotional level). The juxtaposition of a senseless game of chance and overwhelming feeling hits a raw nerve and keeps tapping at it. This scene tells you all you need to know about why De Niro and Walken are some of the best to ever do it.

My father certainly agrees with me here. The scene was so intense for his date at the theater back in 1978 that she got up and left…and then proceeded to break up with him when he refused to leave with her! (Some movies are just too good to walk away from.) Don’t worry, it all worked out in the end: his next girlfriend eventually became his wife. Without the Russian roulette scene being as intense as it is, I wouldn’t be here to talk about its merits forty years later. Your head might start spinning if you think about that time loop too much. Thanks, Michael Cimino!

As the film celebrates its 40th anniversary this month, take a moment to appreciate one of most finely crafted moments in cinematic history.


Thank you for reading! What are your thoughts on The Deer Hunter?  Comment down below!

 If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to MovieBabble via email to stay up to date on the latest content.

Join MovieBabble on Patreon so that new content will always be possible.

What movie topic should I discuss next? Whether it be old or new, the choice is up to you!

*Quotations via Vanity Fair and RogerEbert.com

Advertisements

Nick Kush

A current young professional, Nick founded MovieBabble in October of 2016 in order to provide insightful film analysis that is meant to educate and entertain. Nick is also a member of the Internet Film Critics Society. You can follow Nick at the official MovieBabble Twitter account @MovieBabble_

10 Responses

  1. Ken Dowell says:

    The short answer is yes.

  2. The Deer Hunter is one of my favorite movies specifically because of the detail it goes into showing how war has changed these three soldiers. Platoon is a better depiction of the war, in my opinion, but no other war film shows the before and after as well as this one. Historical accuracy isn’t the point of the Russian roulette sequence—the point is to show that the violence and casualties in war are senseless, with no allegiance to a soldier’s affiliation or morality. The ending sequence with the people back home singing “God Bless America” is just them trying to attribute some meaning, some grand purpose to war, but it’s pretty clear from the film that there’s no meaning or purpose. This is undoubtedly the smartest war film I’ve seen, and I’m still unpacking everything in the film even months after viewing it. Great write-up.

    • Nick Kush says:

      It’s a shame we don’t get more films like this on a grand scale, isn’t it? You’re right, it’s such an intelligent flick that remains insightful today because it took so many chances and never held the audience’s hand. Thanks so much for your thoughts! (And apologies for the late response!)

  3. anne leueen says:

    I saw this film at a press screening in London. I knew nothing about the film other than it was about Vietnam and the war. The opening sequence is so long that I had forgotten Vietnam and the war altogether when BAM it goes there. I really liked this film. Back then I do not remember there was a controversy about the Russian Roulette. For me this was THE Vietnam War movie. Apocalypse Now was also very strong but the Deerhunter was it for me.

  4. I haven’t seen this film but now I wish I had. The authenticity issue is something I think a lot about. Including something ahistorical (like Russian roulette in Vietnam) works when it fits in the story and serves the larger message of the story, as it seems to do here. I can’t stand when filmmakers make up something in a historical or historically based film just because they have a personal message they want to interject. I guess it’s a fine line but I think this is a good example of when it works

    • Nick Kush says:

      For the longest time I was all about complete authenticity. I figured if they ever made a movie about my life (that might be the most boring movie ever made 😂) that I would want total accuracy. But over time I’ve moved my stance more towards capturing the spirit of the situation or person. Tackling on a thematic level works much better for me now. I think The Deer Hunter does this beautifully!

  5. Nick Kush says:

    Join the MovieBabble staff: https://moviebabblereviews.com/join-moviebabble/

    Like MovieBabble on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/moviebabblereviews/

    Follow MovieBabble on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/moviebabble/

    Follow MovieBabble on Twitter: https://twitter.com/MovieBabble_

Leave a Comment Below!

%d bloggers like this: