The Bye Bye Man (2017): A Future Ironic Classic

The first horror movie of the year is here and boy is it s doozy for all the wrong reasons.  The following review will be spoiler free so that you can go see the movie for yourself (although you probably shouldn’t).  Make sure to comment at the bottom of the page with your own thoughts!

the bye bye man

image via Pop Sugar


The Bye Bye Man is directed by Stacy Title and stars Doug Jones as the Bye Bye Man along with Douglas Smith as Elliot, Cressida Jones as Sasha, and Lucien Laviscount as John.  The film follows Elliot, Sasha, and John as they all move into a new house together off the campus of their college.  Everything seems fine until they find a piece of furniture in the house that is connected to the Bye Bye Man who gains power over people the more they say his name or think about him.  As the idea of the Bye Bye Man seeps into the minds of our three leads, we begin to see the wrath of our villain.


I had my reservations about this movie since it’s a low budget horror movie coming out in January.  The month is notorious for having less than stellar horror movies that unfortunately almost always make their money back, urging major movie distributors to continue to make them without much care.  However, The Bye Bye Man has a great premise going for it.  If done correctly, The Bye Bye Man himself has the opportunity to join the other iconic horror villains.  A villain that takes a stronger hold of you the more you think about him is as clever as it is scary.

Moreover, Doug Jones is a great character actor to make the villain.  He might not be a household name (probably due to the fact that he almost always under makeup of some kind), but he always gives inspired performances whether it be in Pan’s Labyrinth as the Pale Man or even in Hellboy as Abe Sapien.  He has an uncanny ability to make a completely fantastical character seem real.

Image result for the bye bye man movie

image via

Unfortunately, Doug Jones is completely wasted as The Bye Bye Man as the movie a whole falters mightily.

What I Liked

I will give this movie credit for having a tense, and even creepy, opening scene.  No spoilers obviously, but the cold open set the film in motion very well as we begin by seeing a man attempting to rid the world of the idea of the Bye Bye Man.  This was the one moment in the film that focused on dread and terror in a character.  It’s too bad that the film quickly derailed from there.

What I Didn’t Like

Acting can make or break a film.  And in the case of The Bye Bye Man, the acting of our three leads makes the film fall really flat.  A good horror film builds upon likeable lead characters that we cheer for to beat their supernatural foe.  However, from the first sequence of dialogue from these three, you immediately want them to meet their demise at the hands of the Bye Bye Man.  I can’t imagine the script was that well-written for this movie, but our three leads are terribly unconvincing and even laughable at times.

Image result for the bye bye man movie

image via Metacritic

However, in a horror film you can get away with subpar acting at times if you follow it up with a creepy vibe and white-knuckling scares.  But a lot of the attempted scares just ended with the audience laughing.  Most, if all, of the scares are carried out with practically zero grace or care.  This film may end up getting a cult following down the road that view it sarcastically because they’re definitely some unplanned laughs to be had due to uneasy direction.

The Bye Bye Man also has a serious pacing issue.  For the first 45 minutes or so of the film, practically nothing happens to the three leads, which leads us to have to deal with poor acting as they crux of our “entertainment.”  I saw what the film was going for in trying to slowly ratchet up the tension as the Bye Bye Man slowly takes hold, but it was not done effectively whatsoever.  The film was also weirdly edited, which attributes to this pacing issue.  Scenes abruptly cut and change, sometimes even cutting away from a possible scare to more bad dialogue.

Image result for the bye bye man movie

image via Spy Hollywood

What I Didn’t Like…Continued

The Bye Bye Man initially had an R rating but then was marked down to a PG-13 rating.  This fact makes me wonder if there were a lot of scares early in the film that the MPAA deemed unworthy of a PG-13 movie.  This type of move, if true, appears to be a decision based completely on profit for the distribution company so that it would allow for a wider audience to see the movie.  Either way, the PG-13 rating definitely hampers this film in unnecessary ways, leaving you to witness horribly clichéd horror plot points over and over again.


All and all, The Bye Bye Man boils down to a practically unwatchable film unless viewed in a sarcastic way.  It gets a D-.  This movie could get a reboot years down the line and be incredibly scary if put in the right hands.  Until then, stream another horror movie like The Conjuring and save your money!


Image result for the bye bye man movie

image via Bloody Disgusting!


Thanks for reading?  Have you seen The Bye Bye Man?  Better yet (since you shouldn’t see this movie in theaters), who’s your favorite horror icon?  Comment down below with your thoughts!

If you enjoyed this review, please like, share, and subscribe.

What should I discuss next?  Whether it be old or new, the choice is up to you!  Thanks for reading!




Nick Kush

A current college, Nick founded MovieBabble in October of 2016 in order to grow his own movie knowledge as well as share his thoughts with others in a streamlined fashion. As MovieBabble continues to grow, Nick hopes to one day become a reputable critic that many turn to first for a quality movie review.

You may also like...

21 Responses

  1. inkbiotic says:

    I keep seeing this advertised and hoped it would be good, because like you say, the premise is great. Shame it falls down on so many other points. Great review though!

  2. piratepatty says:

    Ah I was hoping this one would be good. Thank you for the review!

  3. The trailer looked promising but I had a feeling it would be a dud. Thanks for saving me time and money 😉

  4. I can’t wait to see this movie! I hope it’s total schlock.

  5. I was so excited for this movie and hopeful for a huge horror hit in January. Thank goodness for Split saving the day!

  6. I’ve heard there’s a really weird singing scene near the end. Is it as bad as I’m hearing?

    • MovieBabble says:

      It’s pretty horrendous, but also laugh out loud funny! I think they tried to make it a fun little nod to the plot since “bye” is like the most common word in the song, but it just comes off as completely cheesy since the acting is just so bad lol.

  7. Haven’t read this because I don’t read reviews before I see a movie so I give my unbiased opinion. But as far as watching the trailers (I did want to try this in the theater but very hesitant) reminds me of the Babadook meets Candyman (maybe) ?

  8. tayahmay says:

    I laughed so much, especially at the jump scares. Lol but I liked that twist where the little girl saw the words in the draw but couldn’t read them because she doesn’t read in the dark. That was clever.

  1. February 2, 2017

    […] *To read my review of The Bye Bye Man, please click here […]

Leave a Reply

Donate to MovieBabbleSee Our GoFundMe
+ +
%d bloggers like this: